Skip to content
GitLab
Explore
Sign in
Primary navigation
Search or go to…
Project
S
sgdt
Manage
Activity
Members
Labels
Plan
Issues
Issue boards
Milestones
Wiki
Code
Merge requests
Repository
Branches
Commits
Tags
Repository graph
Compare revisions
Snippets
Build
Pipelines
Jobs
Pipeline schedules
Artifacts
Deploy
Releases
Package registry
Model registry
Operate
Environments
Terraform modules
Monitor
Incidents
Analyze
Value stream analytics
Contributor analytics
CI/CD analytics
Repository analytics
Model experiments
Help
Help
Support
GitLab documentation
Compare GitLab plans
Community forum
Contribute to GitLab
Provide feedback
Keyboard shortcuts
?
Snippets
Groups
Projects
Show more breadcrumbs
gradual-typing
sgdt
Commits
693dc0bf
Commit
693dc0bf
authored
6 years ago
by
Max New
Browse files
Options
Downloads
Patches
Plain Diff
more response edits (900 still)
parent
f214f14b
No related branches found
Branches containing commit
No related tags found
No related merge requests found
Changes
1
Hide whitespace changes
Inline
Side-by-side
Showing
1 changed file
popl19/response2.md
+4
-4
4 additions, 4 deletions
popl19/response2.md
with
4 additions
and
4 deletions
popl19/response2.md
+
4
−
4
View file @
693dc0bf
We thank the reviewers for their very helpful feedback and will revise
the paper accordingly. In particular, we will expand on the motivation
for using CBPV.
for using CBPV
and clearly state our contributions
.
1.
Reviewer C says "Moreover, the paper doesn't produce any particular
equalities that one might want to reason with while programming."
...
...
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ contextually equivalent. We do include beta-eta in the definition of
term dynamism in figure 4, where they are labeled as axioms of term
dynamism, but this is not enough to prove completeness for an
effectful language like cbpv: for instance, both sequential and
non-deterministic languages
should model all of the axioms
.
non-deterministic languages
model beta-eta
.
The syntax is not intended to be complete for any particular language,
in order that it apply to as many as possible. This is what allows us
...
...
@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ https://newtraell.cs.uchicago.edu/research/publications/techreports/TR-2004-02
4.
Reviewer D asks to clarify lines 116-117.
Yes, we mean that the typed equivalences should hold in the statically
typed portions of the code;
the dynamic typ
e casts ensure that the
typed portions of the code;
but th
e casts ensure that the
equivalences hold in statically typed portions of the code even if they
interact with (more) dynamically typed code. We expect that it will be
rare for gradually typed programs to be completely typed (e.g. this is
...
...
@@ -85,7 +85,7 @@ effects.
7.
Reviewer A asks "(l35) eta is mostly used in one direction for optimization, it's
the other direction that fails for these cases right?"
Yes, in the
"
eager
"
cast semantics, the eta law for functions should be
Yes, in the eager cast semantics, the eta law for functions should be
an ordering
`V <= \x -> V x`
but it's debateable whether this means that
the right should be allowed to be optimized to the left. This would make
the semantics of the program dependent on the precise behavior of the
...
...
This diff is collapsed.
Click to expand it.
Preview
0%
Loading
Try again
or
attach a new file
.
Cancel
You are about to add
0
people
to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Save comment
Cancel
Please
register
or
sign in
to comment